Criminal Mischief is one of the most commonly charged offenses in Larimer County and one of the most misunderstood. Many people are shocked to discover that what felt like a minor incident can result in felony charges, thousands of dollars in restitution, and a permanent criminal record. Whether the alleged incident happened in Fort Collins, Loveland, Estes Park, Berthoud, Timnath, Wellington, or Windsor, here is what you need to know.
Fort Collins Criminal Mischief Lawyer: What Is Criminal Mischief in Colorado?
Under Colorado Revised Statute § 18-4-501, Criminal Mischief occurs when a person knowingly damages the real or personal property of another person. This includes a wide range of conduct, like smashing a car window, spray-painting graffiti on a building, breaking a fence, damaging a phone during an argument, or destroying furniture inside a home.
The offense does not require intent to cause a specific dollar amount of harm. It requires only that you knowingly caused the damage; meaning you were aware that your actions would damage the property.
How Is Criminal Mischief Charged in Colorado? A Loveland Criminal Mischief Attorney Explains
Like Theft, Criminal Mischief is a tiered offense. The charge level is determined by the total value of the property damaged:
- Under $300 — Petty offense, up to 10 months in jail and fines up to $300
- $300–$999 — Class 2 misdemeanor, up to 120 days in jail
- $1,000–$1,999 — Class 1 misdemeanor, up to 364 days in jail
- $2,000–$4,999 — Class 6 felony, 12–18 months in prison
- $5,000–$19,999 — Class 5 felony, 1–3 years in prison
- $20,000–$99,999 — Class 4 felony, 2–6 years in prison
- $100,000 or more — Class 3 felony, 4–12 years in prison
One detail that catches many people off guard: prosecutors can aggregate the value of damage across multiple incidents into a single charge, much like they can with Theft offenses. If the same person is accused of damaging property on multiple occasions, the total dollar amount can be combined to elevate the charge to a higher level.
Can Criminal Mischief Be a Domestic Violence Offense in Larimer County?
It can be and this is one of the most important things to understand about how these cases arise in Larimer County. When Criminal Mischief is alleged to have occurred during a dispute between people in an intimate relationship, it is typically charged as a Domestic Violence offense under Colorado law.
A Domestic Violence designation does not create a separate charge, but it adds a mandatory sentence enhancer that triggers a series of serious consequences: a mandatory protection order, required DV treatment, and a prohibition on possessing firearms under both state and federal law. It also makes any future offense subject to habitual Domestic Violence offender provisions, which can result in felony sentencing even for what would otherwise be a misdemeanor.
In Larimer County, law enforcement in Fort Collins, Loveland, and throughout the county are trained to identify and charge Domestic Violence related Criminal Mischief aggressively. The 8th Judicial District Attorney’s Office has a dedicated Domestic Violence unit, and these cases are rarely dismissed simply because the alleged victim later wants to drop the matter.
I Was Charged with Criminal Mischief in Fort Collins: What If the Property Was Partially Mine?
This is a question that comes up frequently in domestic situations. For example, when someone damages a shared vehicle, a jointly owned television, or property inside a shared home. Colorado courts have held that damaging jointly owned property can still support a Criminal Mischief charge, since the other owner has an ownership interest you are not entitled to destroy. It is not a complete defense to say the property was “partly mine.”
Can I Be Required to Pay Restitution for My Loveland Criminal Mischief Case?
Yes. Colorado law requires courts to order full restitution to crime victims as part of any sentence. In Criminal Mischief cases, this means the defendant can be ordered to pay the full repair or replacement cost of the damaged property, regardless of whether they receive jail time, probation, or a deferred sentence. Restitution obligations survive bankruptcy and can follow you for years.
Charged with Criminal Mischief in Fort Collins, Loveland, or Anywhere in Larimer County?
A Criminal Mischief charge, especially one carrying a Domestic Violence designation or a felony-level damage amount, can have consequences that last long after the case is closed. Contact our office today for a confidential consultation and let us help you understand your options.
If you or someone you love has been charged with Criminal Mischief, be smart, exercise your right to remain silent, and contact the best criminal defense attorneys from the O’Malley Law Office at 970-658-0007 to schedule a free initial consultation. Together, we can protect your future.
Image by Jacques GAIMARD from Pixabay